Chocolate Fudge Pie Recipe

Pie meets fudge in a way your guests will love!

You’ve got some work to build this pie, but it’s go to be the best ever!

Honestly, professional caterers seldom make pie crust from scratch. Read about how we do it, and how you can save lots of time too:Caterer’s Pie Secrets gives you lots of ideas, especially for larger parties.

We like to do things quickly and not have to mess with something too much. But this is an exception to our rule. Our baker wrinkles up her nose a little when she sees this one the menu, because she knows that extra time needs to be budgeted - maybe even an extra person if we have lots to do.

But - we would not go through this if it we're worth it. You see when you taste it. Perfection.

Remember that good baking is more like careful chemistry. Measure your ingredients, avoid substitutions, and use ASK-a-CATERER for free party recipes and ideas.

Portions/ServingsThis recipe will feed 8 people, making one pie.
Read about Party Food Quantities to plan for more or less.


1 cup white sugar
1/2 cup cocoa
2 cups milk
6 tablespoons flour
2 egg yolks
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1 tablespoon butter (no substitute)
1 pie shell,baked


In a medium saucepan, combine everything except the butter and vanilla. Stirring constantly, slowly cook it until it thickens, usually a few minutes after you see a bubble.

Remove from heat and allow to cool for 5 minutes. Then add the butter and vanilla.

Immediately pour the fudge into your pie crust.

Allow to cool overnight. When serving, warm your knife blade in hot water and wipe clean after each cut.

Use your pie crust, or learn how we do it the easy and fast way:Caterer’s Pie Secrets

We like to use shaved white chocolate, whipped cream and sometimes chopped nuts for the topping.

A variation on this recipe is to add pecans.

Questions about the Chocolate Fudge Pie Recipe?
Use ASK-a-CATERER for answers to all your party food questions.
It’s FREE!!!

How about some more Chocolate Dessert Recipes?

Take Me Home to Party Recipes and Ideas!

Back to the TOP of Chocolate Fudge Pie Recipe

Best Food Warmer,
our most popular,
really inexpensive,
home party perfect!

Our favorite knife - we use
it 85% of the time. Cheap
knifes should be illegal.